Content Harry Potter
 
Back to: Harry Potter » The Refiner's Fire » Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry

The Refiner's Fire

By Abraxan

Previous Next
Name: Dragnew
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Monday 12th January 2009 4:21pm

I suppose you're getting sick of all this by now, but you also write an excellent Snape. I'm going to keep this comment brief, but it is so good to see Harry joking again. Also, your Dumbledore feels much more grandfatherly than the one in Canon ever did. It's been a while since I last read ToD, but I seem to recall there's a good reason for that. Anyway, I'm looking forward to Harry getting back to Hogwarts. Next Chapter, AWAY!

Reply from: Abraxan

I'm glad you like my Snape and that you find Dumbledore grandfatherly!  I had fun writing them!

And I don't get tired of reading comments about my stories!  thanks for writing!

Abraxan

Name: Sond
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Tuesday 29th July 2008 6:39am

Ok, never mind my whining about Casey dying just to have a H/G fic.
It was brilliant to think of something like that to make Harry sick and poor Casey was just perfect for it! You described her enough to let us know how Harry feels but you kept enough distance to allow us to read on without many problems.

Besides it would have been so cliché to let Harry get sick of is grieve for Sirius os you solved that very good with an OC.

Carrying on then :)
Sammy

Reply from: Abraxan

I'm glad you understand why I did what I did!  Thanks!  And yeah, I didn't want to write a cliche'd story.  Glad you're enjoying it!

Abraxan

Name: Jenifer Winterbine
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Sunday 22nd June 2008 11:40pm

I would like to congratulate your Brit pickers . It is so rare - and such a pleasure - to read a fic set in the UK , written by an American but wihout having one's 'suspension of disbelief' jarringly and repeatedly challenged by screamingly 'wrong' American expressions and habits in every other paragraph.
BTW you forgot a funeral for Sirius the dog or at least some explanation of what had happened to his body.

Reply from: Abraxan

I'm so sorry I missed seeing this review!  Thanks a lot for your kind words about my Brit-picker!  She's British-born and has traveled the world but still lives in England.  She does a really good job.

Yup, I left out Sirius the dog's funeral, but Harry was so devastated by Casey's death that he couldn't think about the poor dog.  Since the story is from Harry's POV, I left it out because of that.

Abraxan

Name: TxA_GunFighter
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Thursday 22nd May 2008 12:47pm

Good chapter.

gunny

Reply from: Abraxan

Thanks!

Abraxan

Name: jake m
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Saturday 11th March 2006 9:51pm

grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr if ginny and harry get together that is betryal !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and i dont see why u made the muggle girl die she was awsome makes me want to hate u and send u horrible letters.
all in all means u wrote that very well and have me emotionalyl involved now.

singed
-antoine

Reply from: Abraxan

ROTFL! You can't imagine how many reviews I've gotten with folks yelling at me for killing off poor Casey. She's gone but not forgotten - keep reading (all the way through "The Time of Destiny," Refiner's sequel) and you'll see what I mean. And I'm using Casey as a character in the original novel I'm working on now, simply because she was so popular with readers. Thanks for writing!

Abraxan

Name: Wooster
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Wednesday 30th November 2005 11:14am

Whee! Ginny/Harry stuff already springing. I did love Casey and all, but she's not Ginny. She was perfect for him at that stage of his life though, so yay her! Snape is so...mean. Obviously he's on the 'good guy' side, but still...hmm...

Boy, Harry's temper is a problem, good thing about the pheonix song making him all tranquil...oh wait.

Name: The Resident
Chapter: Chapter 11 - More Homework for Harry
Posted On: Friday 11th November 2005 2:53am

Alittle more light-hearted. Quite nice actually.

Displaying 1 to 7 of 7.
Previous Next
bottom left