Sinfield4 posted a comment on Thursday 5th April 2018 4:06pm

Fantastic storyline. I have enjoyed reading them. Thank you

Rocket Lucy posted a comment on Monday 8th May 2017 11:46pm

Fantastic. What else can I say. I always tell people to read Bobmin for a good fan fiction, but I think yours is right up there with theirs. The only mistake that caught my attention was when Madeye Moody went to Grimmauld to fetch Ginny's engagement ring, and there was no mention of the wards Harry put up to keep people out of his room. Everything else was perfect. My eyes were burning, I read so late into the night. Thank you so much for sharing.

noylj posted a comment on Tuesday 2nd June 2015 12:51am

Why aren't Ron's bone fragments vanished and he gets a dose of skeleton-grow?

irishbloodinmyveins posted a comment on Sunday 8th February 2015 5:21pm

Absolutely outstanding fictional writing! I sincerely enjoyed reading both refiners fire and The Time Of Destiny. Thank you, thank you, thank you! What an inspiring couple of stories u absolutely had me hooked from the first chapter of refiner's!!!!! Xxxx

Jedi Master Albus posted a comment on Thursday 24th January 2013 7:08am

I know this story is old now but I just wanted to make a suggestion... In Britain, the age of legal consent to drink alcohol is 18, which you know. But that is for Muggles, as their 18th birthday is the day they come of age. For wizards it's 17, and as this story is about British wizards I would assume they would be allowed to drink alcohol at 17 as well... Admittedly there is not really any proof for this except the fact that Harry first drinks firwhisky not long before his 17th birthday, but at the time this story was being done, you wouldn't have known.. Just figured I would make a suggestion...

lwj2 posted a comment on Tuesday 20th March 2012 8:02am

This is great.

Neville's grandfather as a toad, cool. It will be interesting to see what you've done with what purports to be a very angry Augusta.

Thanks for writing and sharing this.

kyoshi posted a comment on Saturday 5th November 2011 9:06pm

You made Harry really wimpy in this story. I enjoy Harry when he has a backbone. Harry is so sensitive in this story, you should call it Mary Jane and Thelma.

Terrible Tues posted a comment on Wednesday 28th September 2011 9:29am

Good pair of fics.

Terrible Tues posted a comment on Sunday 25th September 2011 3:47am

Good chapter!

Terrible Tues posted a comment on Wednesday 21st September 2011 7:26pm

What about the Muggle woman killed by Augusta Longbottom?

SassyFrass posted a comment on Monday 29th August 2011 2:16pm

So I was rereading this great story again for the hundredth time, and I noticed something that I believe is a continuity issue. McGonagall talks about Pettigrew being an animagus alive and well, working for Voldemort. Except didn't Harry kill Pettigrew at the battle in France in 'Refiner's Fire?'
Anyway, still love the story.

tcl7189 posted a comment on Saturday 22nd January 2011 12:57am

GREAT GREAT RIDE!!! Loved the whole story...both of them!!! Although was starting to wonder if you were really planning to off Harry with as many times as he was injured After Moldyshorts died!!!...lol...Thanks for the hard work!!!

tcl7189 posted a comment on Saturday 22nd January 2011 12:55am

GREAT GREAT RIDE!!! Loved the whole story...both of them!!! Although was starting to wonder if you were really planning to off Harry with as many times as he was injured After Moldyshorts died!!!...lol...Thanks for the hard work!!!

sammiscott32 posted a comment on Saturday 4th December 2010 1:31pm

I really liked these two books :) I think you are a fantasic writer :)

Teh_General_Lee posted a comment on Saturday 7th August 2010 12:40am

Don't take this the wrong way or anything, it's a great story, but why does everyone seem to have serious anger issues? Seriously, Ron storms into a hospital and looks about ready to kill someone cos his friend is sleeping when he arrived

Ginny-Potter-123 posted a comment on Monday 19th July 2010 6:30pm

This Story Was Awsome!!!!! I Loved It! The characters were intense and the plot was captivating! All in all i really enjoyed it! Now im going to read The Refiner's Fire because i didnt realize untill like chapter 19 that there was a different story before this lol! Again Great Story!

marchemort posted a comment on Wednesday 14th July 2010 12:16am

Those stories where quite fantastic, even if I am not a big fan myself of the Harry/Ginny relationship ( I was kind of sad when Casey died back in the begining of the refiner's fire)

Excellent fictions all around, congratulations! (:

Ginny-Potter-123 posted a comment on Monday 12th July 2010 10:39pm

So I didnt notice untill a few chapters ago that there was a story before this and while it hasnt effected my reading so far i was wonderin if it will in the future? Anyway great story so far ive really enjoyed it!

ily.the.cat posted a comment on Wednesday 26th May 2010 6:01pm

Hi. I absolutely love your stories. Everything is well thought out and there are no discrepancies that I can see. Anyway, the only thing I have a question on is what is the final order of things. If you could let me know by replying to this or emailing me at ily.the.cat@gmail.com that'd be amazing. Thanks so much. - I.T.C

rengoddess posted a comment on Wednesday 12th May 2010 2:28am

I cried through, Prolly 2/3's of this chapter. The fact that I did says VOLUMES about your ability to write! I was very moved. I wasn't going to review until I read the whole story but I felt that this was worth a mention.

Thanks for bringing us such an amazing story!